Lawsuit Filed for City Commission Change

Single Member Districting is an issue that just won't go away in Amarillo.

Some people are now saying the way people voted was illegal and have filed a lawsuit against the city.

NewsChannel 10's Jennifer Best  has the story on this evolving issue.

When people went to the polls in November they voted for or against one issue.... Calling for single member districting as well as increasing the number of city commissioners.

Here's where the disagreement comes in.... Some say those are two separate issues and should not have been joined together as one.

"All we are saying is do it the proper way....follow the law and for pete sake if the leaders of the city can't follow the law then you have to take them to task." Philip Russ is a local attorney who filed a lawsuit Tuesday against the City of Amarillo.

He was hired by one of committee members who started the petition which allowed single member districting to be on the ballot. Russ says the city originally had the proposals as two separate items... But changed it into one and that's the way it ended up on the ballot.

Russ says Texas state law says you have to separate every single proposal. " We think the statute is clear it says if there is a separate question for the voter to pass on it has to be on a separate proposition on the ballot, that you can't bundle or bunch them up."

The City of Amarillo sent us this official comment.  It says the city denies the accusations in the lawsuit.  The city firmly believes that state law supports having both items in one proposition.

According to the city, state courts have previously ruled that if a single subject has several elements, it may be submitted in one proposition. 

Russ argues combining theses item could have affected the way people voted. He says the city has 20 days to respond to the lawsuit. It could be settled between the two or go to trial.

Russ says if they win the city will have another election. He says if the city wins... Things will stay as is. 

NewsChannel 10 will be following this story and keep you updated with what the city does and if there will be another election. 

Related Stories:

1. Amarillo City Commission To Remain
A hot topic on the ballot this year was the Single Member District proposal. Although it was a close race, voters decided to *not* pass the ordinance which means you will continue to vote for Amarillo city leaders at large. Overall, more than 17-thousand people voted in favor of Single Member...
Last Modified 12/04/2006 06:07:01 PM
2. City Commission Makeup on the Ballot
Single Member Districts---it's a hot issue on this year's ballot and Tuesday voters will decide whether to allow it. Here's some information you may want to think about before casting your vote. The Single Member District debate began this year when attorney J.E. Sauseda began a petition back...
Last Modified 12/04/2006 06:07:05 PM
3. Single Member District Petition Submitted to City
A petition signed by more than seven thousand registered voters in the City of Amarillo was submitted to the City Secretary this morning. The "Concerned Citizens for Fair Representation" has been collecting signatures of those who want to put the "Single Member District" voting system initiative...
Last Modified 12/01/2006 06:57:03 PM
4. Single Member District Debate
A heated debate today between attorney J.E. Sauseda and the Amarillo City Commission ends with the single member district issue as one amendment on the November ballot. It was back in January when Sauseda began the petition for single member districts that would elect eight city commissioners....
Last Modified 09/11/2006 05:20:38 PM
5. Local Attorney Out to Change the Makeup of City Commission
Attorney J.E. Sauseda says today he has just under 4,000 signatures for his referendum to force the city to adopt single-member districts. He started the petition back in January and hopes to present 6,000 signatures by July 21st to current city officials in order to force it on the November...
Last Modified 08/29/2006 05:56:49 PM